The Best Barefoot Shoes for Women (My Honest Favorites After 3+ Years)
Curious about barefoot shoes? After wearing them nearly exclusively for 5+ years, I’m chiming in with my favorite options in every category!
Not only are these shoe options comfy and supportive of your foot health, but they are versatile and aesthically pleasing too, which is always a plus!
Over the last three years, I've gradually replaced nearly every pair of shoes I own with barefoot shoes. I've worn them through pregnancy, thousands of travel miles, hundreds of gym workouts, hiking, everyday errands, and family life. These are the pairs I'd actually buy again.
Maybe it's that I am approaching 30... Or maybe it's because I had terrible foot pain during my first pregnancy and needed a solution.. or maybe I got one too many ingrown toenails and had enough.
Whichever was the ultimate motivation, I am so thankful I ventured into the world of minimalist footwear. I wanted a new shoe that would support my body, be versatile enough for everyday wear, and be comfy (while not giving dad shoe, orthotic vibes… ya know??)
This post will share all my favorite, tried-and-true barefoot shoe faves!
TLDR: Kaelyn’s Faves
Best Overall Barefoot Shoes: Lems
Best Barefoot Sneakers: Minnemals
Best Budget Barefoot Shoes: Whitin
Best Barefoot Sandal: Earth Runners
Best Boots: Lems
Table of Contents
My Barefoot Shoe Journey
Three years ago, I wasn't planning to replace every pair of shoes in my closet.
I simply became curious about barefoot shoes after learning more about foot strength, natural movement, and how modern footwear changes the way we walk.
Since then, barefoot shoes have gradually become my everyday footwear.
I've worn them:
while traveling internationally and walking 20,000+ steps a day
through pregnancy
hiking and backpacking
lifting weights
walking on my treadmill
chasing my kids around the park
running everyday errands
Today, I reach for barefoot shoes almost every day—not because I think everyone has to wear them, but because I've genuinely found them more comfortable. Since beginning to wear barefoot shoes, I have experienced:
reduced foot pain. We used to have tile in our kitchen and after even 20 minutes standing barefoot and washing dishes, my arches would be aching. For a long time I blamed this on the tile.. But later I learned that is was probably due to weak feet. After wearing more minimalist footwear and spending more time being barefoot, I started noticing less and less foot pain. Now, I hardly ever notice foot pain (even when walking 20,000+ miles on our Italian vacation)
Traditional shoes are not worth the squished toes-- I am now slowly in the process of replacing all my different styles of shoes with more minimal shoes. No more high heels, or pointy-toe boots around here anymore. I am at a point in my life where I much prefer the function of my shoes versus the aesthetic (although there are starting to be a lot more cute options with a minimalist design).
One of the most noticeable differences was with workouts- strong feet led to strong ankles, knees, and overall stability. Feeling the ground and having a super flexible sole, helped my feet to engage. This created better balance and motion control both in and out of the gym. I've lifted weights for years, but it wasn't until I started wearing shoes with a flat sole that I really noticed a big shift in my compound lifts like deadlift and squat.
Foot shape- As I have worn these shoes on a regular basis, i have noticed my feet becoming slightly more wide. This is not something that bothers me but it is something to be aware of. On the special occasion where I do wear a "normal shoe" or one that is a bit more narrow, my wide feet feel a bit more pinched.
That said, not all barefoot shoes are created equal.
Some are incredibly comfortable.
Some are...not.
This guide includes the shoes I have personally worn, tested, and would actually recommend to a friend.
What Makes a Good Barefoot Shoe?
Not every shoe marketed as "barefoot" checks all of the boxes.
Here are the features I personally look for:
A wide toe box that allows your toes to spread naturally
A zero-drop sole (meaning the heel isn't elevated)
A flexible sole that bends with your foot
Lightweight construction
Comfortable materials that don't restrict movement
Good durability for everyday wear
Personally, I also want something that looks nice and doesn’t look awkward and clunky like some barefoot shoes available…
If you want to learn more about barefoot shoes and how they support your health, this blog post is a great resource.
How I Chose My Favorite Barefoot Shoes
Rather than simply recommending the most popular brands, I prioritized shoes that I have personally worn and can honestly speak to after months—or years—of use.
As an RN and health coach, I also looked for shoes that encouraged natural movement while still being practical for everyday life.
When evaluating each shoe, I considered:
Comfort
Durability
Flexibility
Value
Everyday wearability
Style
How often I actually reached for them
Best Overall Barefoot Shoe Brand
There are many barefoot shoe brands out there. But if I had to choose just one, it would be Lems. As a shoe brand, they have the most versatile options that support overall foot health.
Whether you are looking for hiking shoes, sandals, snow boots, or everyday sneakers, Lems has options for men and women.
I also appreciate that anytime I have had a question or needed help with sizing, I have had a great experience with their customer service.
Plus, any of their shoes I own have held up well for years.
Best Barefoot Everyday Shoes
If you haven’t caught on to my personal preference yet, I love versatility in a shoe. As a registered nurse, homeschooling mom of two young kids, and business owner, I’m often on the go. I want a shoe that looks good, stays comfortable all day, and can keep up with our lifestyle.
I’ve worn Minnemals barefoot shoes for the last couple of months, and they have become something I reach for again and again. I love that they are a high-quality, aesthetic shoe option for everyday wear.
I’ve really loved my experience with this shoe brand and hope they continue expanding into different styles and colors in the future!
Best Barefoot Sandals
peep my fave barefoot sandals-- Earth Runners have been my favorite thing to pack no matter where we are headed!
I’ve owned Earth Runners for 5+ years now. I purchased them multiple times and will continue to do so in the future. I love that they are comfortable, versatile, and support your nervous system through a small copper disc.
This disc allows your body to “ground” through contact with the Earth, while still having protection on your feet.
I have worn these sandals hiking, getting baptized in the river, walking 20,000+ steps a day traveling, and simply running errands.
10/10 recommend for a great sandal option!
Best Barefoot Boots
For years, I have loved the look of Blundstone boots. I love that they are versatile enough to be dressed up or down and are extremely functional, while also being known for their high-quality construction and materials.
That said, they tend to lean on the more narrow side.
So, that sent me on the search for a great barefoot lookalike!
The Lems boot completely fits the bill!! I’ve owned these for two years now and love them more now than I did when I first got them. They are the perfect boot for transitioning into colder weather!
My favorite boots for on-the-go, rainy fall days, and romping around with my kiddos in the dirt! I opted for the waterproof option in the color “espresso” for the most functionality and versatility.
Best Budget Barefoot Shoe
Looking for the best minimalist shoe without breaking the bank?? I found this shoe brand on Amazon a few years ago and have since bought 3 different pairs. The cool thing is that the price of all three is still less than your major brands offering barefoot shoes. Here are the 3 different shoes I have:
My favorite "trainers"- these are comparable to your typical workout tennis shoe in terms of design! I have these in the army green color and love them soo much. Truly this is my favorite shoe for wearing to the gym.
The best shoe for everyday use- I have this style in both fully black and fully white. I can wear them with jeans or a dress for a casual look, and love how versatile they are.
I regularly lift weights and workout in these Whitin shoes. I appreciate that they are durable, affordable, and support natural foot movement.
How to Transition to Barefoot Shoes
If you are new to the barefoot shoe world, don’t just dive right in. The advice from podiatrists and gait specialists is to start slowly. Your feet may be weakened from traditional shoes, so it will take some time to build up that foot strength.
You can start by wearing them around the house at first, and gradually increasing your wear time.
As with all things health and wellness, make sure you are listening to your body!
Common Mistakes New Barefoot Shoe Wearers Make
Another important note on barefoot shoes— there are a few common mistakes that I see people make when jumping in!
First, they are buying shoes that are not the right size. Make sure you are reading the sizing charts, and if you aren’t sure, reach out to the company for their recommendation! With every single barefoot shoe brand I have tried, there tends to be some variation. Some brands run a bit bigger, some are smaller, and there is tons of variation for width!
As I said before, another mistake is wearing them too much too quickly. Give your feet time to strengthen and get used to having less shoe support.
Another mistake I see, is people assuming that a higher price means a higher quality shoe. Unfortunately, I have tried several of the more expensive barefoot options and been really disappointed. I’ve also been pleasantly surprised by some of the more affordable options. While I do think you generally get what you pay for, I’ve seen so much variation in barefoot shoe quality and construction. Make sure you are checking out the reviews to get a better idea of the customer experience!
Frequently Asked Questions
I’ve gotten a lot of barefoot shoe questions since sharing minimalist shoe content. Here are some of the questions I get most frequently to help you feel confident in your shoe choices!
Are barefoot shoes actually better?
Barefoot shoes aren't necessarily "better" for everyone, they're simply designed differently than conventional shoes. They typically feature a wide toe box, zero-drop sole, and flexible construction that allows your feet to move more naturally. Many people find they improve comfort, balance, and foot strength over time, but they aren't a one-size-fits-all solution. The best choice depends on your lifestyle, foot health, and how gradually you transition.
Are barefoot shoes good for walking?
Yes! Barefoot shoes can be excellent for walking once you've had time to adjust to them. I personally wear mine for everything from everyday errands to long travel days where I'm walking 20,000+ steps. If you're new to barefoot shoes, start with shorter walks and gradually increase your wear time to allow your feet and lower legs to adapt.
What are the best barefoot shoes for beginners?
For most beginners, I recommend choosing a comfortable, versatile everyday shoe rather than the most minimalist option available. A shoe with a flexible sole, wide toe box, and just a little bit of cushioning can make the transition much more comfortable while still allowing you to experience the benefits of barefoot-style footwear.
I also think choosing a more affordable option is good at first, to make sure the transition is something you are actually going to stick with
Do barefoot shoes help strengthen your feet?
Barefoot shoes don't magically strengthen your feet on their own, but they allow the muscles in your feet to work more naturally than many traditional shoes. Over time, some people notice improved foot strength, balance, and stability. Like any muscle group, those changes happen gradually with consistent use and appropriate activity.
Can you wear barefoot shoes all day?
Many people do, but I wouldn't recommend switching overnight if you're brand new to barefoot shoes. Start by wearing them around the house or for short outings before gradually increasing your wear time. Once your feet have adjusted, many people find they're comfortable enough to wear all day.
Are barefoot shoes different than minimalist footwear?
Minimalist footwear is a term used pretty interchangeably with “barefoot shoes”. These are some of the standard assumptions and common features when talking about minimalist shoes or "barefoot shoes"
zero drop -this means that the heel is not raised in comparison to the rest of the shoe
a wide toe box- this means the shoe does not taper in the front and instead has a shape that resembles the shape of a foot (go figure right?)
minimal to no arch support
flexible sole that allows and accommodates for natural foot movement
Are barefoot shoes worth the money?
In my experience, yes. Since switching several years ago, barefoot shoes have become the pairs I reach for most often. While quality barefoot shoes can be more expensive upfront, I've found that well-made pairs have held up well over time and have been worth the investment for how frequently I wear them. If you're unsure, starting with a more budget-friendly option is a great way to see whether you enjoy the barefoot style before investing in premium brands.
Final Thoughts
If someone had told me a few years ago that I'd eventually replace most of my shoe collection with barefoot shoes, I probably wouldn't have believed them.
But after wearing them through travel, workouts, hiking, pregnancy, and everyday life, I genuinely don't see myself going back.
That doesn't mean every barefoot shoe is worth buying.
It also doesn't mean everyone needs the most expensive option.
The best barefoot shoe is the one that fits your feet, your lifestyle, and your budget—and one you'll actually wear consistently.
Hopefully this guide helps narrow down the options and makes that decision a little easier. If you have questions, my inbox is always open. I’d love to try to answer any of your barefoot shoe questions or point you in the right direction to finding an answer!
Kaelyn
Related Reads:
Latest on the blog…
Looking for healthy fall meal ideas? Learn how I use a seasonal meal rotation to simplify dinner, save money, and enjoy nourishing meals featuring fall produce.